Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Bella Goodell [resubmit]

EDIT 2 [09/12/2017: Four years after this event, Bella has contacted me today to apologize & make up for her past mistakes as a child. She has sent me the total amount of money that I lost in the chargebacks ($105) as "friends & family" so there is no concern of a future chargeback. I consider this beware to be resolved.

WHO: Bella Goodell
I have done lots of searching, but as far as I can tell, she does not have a Furaffinity [furaffinity found] or Deviantart account, or any way of identifying her other than her real name and her emails. That is why they are here. The real name is important to identify her, even though I understand that real names are not usually posted on Artist Beware. It is also important because she changes account names so frequently.

WHERE: Email.
Known Aliases:
Ponytail_Puller on Instagram [private]
Corgi-Fox on Furaffinity
EDIT: Now changed her name to "ChihuahuaWearingSombrero" on Instagram

I find it likely that she has more. Later half of the email removed by request, if it is needed I can add it back in. 2nd half of the emails are also blacked out in all screenshots.

WHAT: Two digital character references.

WHEN: October 11th 2013 – November 7th 2013

SUMMARY: I was commissioned for 2 character references and later found out that the customer is 13. One month later, she files chargebacks despite being satisfied with the commissions. Customer also uses many email aliases, and at one point tried to commission me under a separate alias (that I now know is her, thanks to the Paypal emails). Customer is unable or unwilling to cancel the chargebacks, Paypal has given the money back to her rather than me, as well as an extra $40 fee. In all, I lost $105 on this, and I’m looking for advice as well as to warn anyone not to work with this individual.

PROOF: All Screenshots can be found here: http://neonslushie.imgur.com/all/

EXPLAIN: Bella Goodell contacted me for a reference commission on October 11th this past month. She followed directions, paid promptly, and I had her reference completed and emailed to her on the 13th. While I do not have the emails from her saying she liked it and was satisfied, she did indeed like the commission. I have all other correspondence with her posted in the screen shot. First Reference Commission - Tango

Several days later, on the 19th, she contacts me for a second character reference. Again, she pays quickly and I am able to get it finished and sent to her a few days later, on the 24th. Again, she is happy with the commission! Second Reference Commission - Cascade

However, here’s where things start to get tricky. Halfway through working on the second reference, I find out that she is 13.
I should have gone with my gut feeling and refunded her money at this point, but the commission was already halfway done, and everything had gone smoothly previously. So the commission is sent out and she is happy.

But it gets weirder. The very same day I had sent out her 2nd finished character sheet, I get an email from her under one of her side-emails.

Correspondence: http://i.imgur.com/xfCiBhC.jpg
Proof that it is her: http://i.imgur.com/0Ic7sPY.jpg

At the time, I did not know it was her. She did not wind up commissioning me this time, but I feel it is important to take note of, as it shows she is sneaky and tries to get around things. I have no idea why she tried to commission me through a side email, but I will be keeping an eye out for her now, and you should too!
Anyways, back to the chargebacks. I got them several weeks after finishing her commissions, with no warning or correspondence beforehand.

1: http://i.imgur.com/9B4UYqt.jpg
2: http://i.imgur.com/0Ic7sPY.jpg

Both of them popped up on November 7th, she had not contacted me previously. I immediately emailed her…  My correspondence with her was confusing at best. I will just leave the describing to the screen caps.

So basically she dances around my questions and does not really answer them, and has given me permission to auction off her characters? Do you think that is wise to do? I have lost a lot of money on this and need to make it back somehow, so I am considering it.

Anyways, after all of this went down, I decided I would no longer be accepting commissions from minors, unless I get permission from their parents. I added a section to my Terms of Service on my website:

All customers must be at least 18 years of age before sending any payments. If under 18, a parent or guardian must contact me before I can accept a commission.

I also added a “Year of Birth” box on my commission form. Since adding these, I have gotten one commission from a minor and it went smoothly, I was able to get a parent to contact me and give permission.

However, I do ask for some advice. What’s stopping some kid from lying about their age? Is there any way I can “scare” them into either telling the truth or not commissioning me? I asked my parents these questions and we came to the conclusion that while we can’t stop them from lying, at least we will have proof that they lied if their parents get them in trouble, contact me, or file a chargeback. But anyways yes, looking for any advice if you have it.

After presenting all of my proof to paypal, paypal sided with Bella rather than me, because the references are not “tangible items”. The $30 and $35 were sent back to Bella… but for each transaction her credit card took an additional $20 as a “service fee”. I am very upset about this because I am now out $105 and there is nothing I can do.

At this point I am just looking to get the word out there that Bella Goodell is not someone you should accept a commission from. There is nothing stopping her from doing this to other people.

Please let me know if there are any questions or if there is any more information you would like me to fill in.

EDIT: As of December 2nd, she has contacted me through her FA Account, offering to pay me back, but telling me to keep the characters up for sale. She also asked me to remove the Beware: http://i.imgur.com/k4GGFhm.jpg

I told her no, I am not comfortable with accepting money from her any more, especially since I currently have the characters up for sale. It is important to note that she now has a Furaffinity account. Beware of Corgi-Fox on FA.

EDIT 2 [09/12/2017: Four years after this event, Bella has contacted me today to apologize & make up for her past mistakes as a child. She has sent me the total amount of money that I lost in the chargebacks ($105) as "friends & family" so there is no concern of a future chargeback. I consider this beware to be resolved.
Artist's beware has moved!
Do NOT repost your old bewares. They are being archived.


Nov. 21st, 2013 08:19 pm (UTC)
I'm not really sure its ethical to be spreading around the full real name of a minor despite the situation.

But you should definitely call PayPal. Sometimes they will return the fees if you explain the situation and its not a recurring issue with your account.

Nov. 21st, 2013 10:25 pm (UTC)
While I absolutely agree, the reason this was allowed was because that name was tied to every single email and one of the prime factors in how this scammer operates. Without any sort of FA or username, there was nothing else to identify them with, and thus no way to warn folks about email-based purchases. If this was conducted through other means then email, then the name wouldn't have been allowed at all.

Sadly, its all people can really go by =\.
Nov. 22nd, 2013 03:15 am (UTC)
Plus, I mean, she can't change her real name. She can change her alias, email, what have you, but not her name.

The name is pretty significant in this case.
Nov. 23rd, 2013 04:47 am (UTC)
I think that makes it EVEN MORE troubling, not less, that her real name is up here. She's 13 and while that's no excuse for scamming people she could grow up and learn from her mistakes and this will still be floating around on google.

It'd be a completely different thing if she were an adult and/or running a business.
Nov. 23rd, 2013 06:03 am (UTC)
While I agree, she is still screwing people over and that's her fault.

She's young and will probably most likely learn from this, but it's her fault nonetheless. Plus we never know, that could be the name of her parent, which in that case, is a little more troubling, but it's not the identity of a minor.

Come to think of it, you have to have all the information to line up (names, birthdays, account numbers, etc) in order to make paypal work in your favor. So I really doubt that's her real name to begin with.
Nov. 23rd, 2013 08:40 am (UTC)
Not necessarily. I used my mom's bank account for a few years, and we don't even share the same last name.

Edit: uh should clarify. I had permission to use it in order to receive payments, I didn't rob my mother or anything of that nature.

Edited at 2013-11-23 08:41 am (UTC)
Nov. 23rd, 2013 08:39 am (UTC)
And you just stumbled upon the very reason that parents need to be supervising their kid's activity.
Nov. 23rd, 2013 04:41 am (UTC)
I understand it's a difficult situation but... that the individual is underage makes it a bit different. People are already doing searches to seek her out and that doesn't sit well with me. Couldn't just her first name be posted along with the list of known emails/paypal email? That's not any less valid than a FA username that can be changed at a whim.

I guess the damage is already done but I'd consider changing the mod's stance on this considering how worried you are about this place being shut down. I know places like Fandom Wank (I know it's on journalfen now but it used to be on lj) forbid postings about minors because of issues in the past.
Nov. 23rd, 2013 12:05 pm (UTC)
If she's posting her name publicly, I'm not sure what the point of excluding it from AB would be?
ETA - oh, maybe she didn't post publicly, just there's no other name? Eh, tough situation, protect scammer vs protect minors...

Edited at 2013-11-23 12:06 pm (UTC)
Nov. 23rd, 2013 04:17 pm (UTC)
Her name is pretty publicly stated on each email (minus the Cricket Fennec) as well as on her Instagram account. So the information is out there.
If the mods decide they would like me to remove her last name from the beware and black it out from the screen caps I would be able to do that when I return from MFF.


A_B icon
Commissioner & Artist, Warning & Kudos Community
Artists Beware

Community Tags

Powered by LiveJournal.com