November 18th, 2015

xibalba

Artist Beware - Honesty.

WHO: Honesty. [current account], Sailor., SailorBases, yoloswagdoctor [old accounts]

WHERE: http://www.furaffinity.net/user/sailorbases/ & http://www.furaffinity.net/user/honesty./

WHAT: Custom bases for my species for rp/adoptables/etc.. 3 separate bases [1 for each species] or 1 base with tons of options for customization.

WHEN: May 29, 2014 - First contact made + commission + price agreed upon + paid.
Asked for update September 2014. Heard nothing back.
Asked for another update on Halloween 2014. Heard back & gave info again.
Heard back Nov. 11 - Offered to try to get sketches for preview that night. I agreed.
Didn't hear back again. Posted public journal about refunding everyone on Christmas day 2014.
June 25, 2015 - Offered art to those who wanted it instead of refund. Took art option.
June 29, 2015 - Sent info to new account when I realized the old one wasn't being checked.
Oct 27, 2015 - Sent a note asking for updates so I could add that to my owed list.
Nov 4, 2015 - Note was read, not responded to. Sent a rather abrupt note asking for a response and got one - asking for all the info again + price paid while indicating I might be refunded instead. Sent info back and stated I would prefer my refund SOON if that was what she preferred to do.

PROOF: Initial PM requesting a base - http://i.imgur.com/KA5MDKm.png
Accepting commission, price given, me accepting it - http://i.imgur.com/cUfXKz0.png
Paypal info given, told her I paid - http://i.imgur.com/mXHL3QA.png
Paypal proof of payment - http://i.imgur.com/j8tQOVI.png
Checking in September 17, 2014 - http://i.imgur.com/ItQhZ05.png
Inquiry on Halloween 2014 - http://i.imgur.com/Btc7IeU.png
Response on Halloween 2014 to my inquiry - http://i.imgur.com/jCe5y8T.png
Offer to sketch things up that night, Nov 11, 2014 - http://i.imgur.com/JSImwcx.png Last contact from them that year.
Refunds instead of art, leaving community, etc journal on Christmas 2014 - http://www.furaffinity.net/journal/6370870/
Offering art instead of refunds June 25, 2015 - http://i.imgur.com/kfd3p1v.png
Telling them I wanted the art instead as per their journal - http://i.imgur.com/D381Bi6.png
Note sent on June 29, 2015 - http://i.imgur.com/thJbatg.png [cut off custom info at bottom of note]
Checked in with them since I saw them posting and doing commissions on Oct 27, 2015 - http://i.imgur.com/szFqbOG.png
I was admittedly short here on Nov 4 2015 due to frustration at seeing them post but not responding to my note - http://i.imgur.com/S82hYoR.png
My final note on Nov 4, 2015 - http://i.imgur.com/OW6Has1.png [blocked out my custom info as I didn't think it necessary to the beware]

EXPLAIN: I commissioned Honesty. back on the 29th of May in 2014. I contacted her asking about a custom base - she had a journal up on her bases account [now abandoned] offering them. Once we'd worked out the details I paid her $36 for them total.

She had a lot of RL issues happen and I was happy to wait. I realized she was not really doing much on her bases account and contacted her on her [then] new account - Sailor.. I didn't get a response initially and contacted her again on Halloween 2014 asking what was going on and for updates. Got a response [you can see in the screencaps above] and I thought everything was worked out. Didn't hear back from her til over a week into November, when she offered to sketch up previews for me to approve. I was happy with that and said as much.

I didn't hear from her again at all that year. On Christmas she posted a journal [listed in proof above] about refunding everyone. I was unhappy since I'd wanted the bases but understood that she'd had a hard time. We got slow updates for a while, with promises of refunds but nothing really being done, up until June.

She made a new journal offering art instead of refunds for those of us who wanted it. I really wanted my art so I contacted her as requested and let her know I'd love to do that instead. I figured she would get on them and it wouldn't be too long a wait. Wrong.

She has taken on many new pieces, continued to work [slowly] on old pieces, but rarely gives updates. I was getting somewhat frustrated and decided to contact her to touch base and see what was up on Oct 27 since I saw she'd been posting owed art and new stuff as well.

My note was read but never responded to, and I saw her continue to post and interact with people on the account. I got somewhat frustrated and sent her a short note requesting a response to my note. She did respond, but indicated she might need to do a refund instead of the work. I responded back letting her know that was fine, but if she was going to refund I'd really prefer it SOON since I've been waiting for almost a year and a half at this point and that is a ridiculous amount of time to be waiting for anything.

At this point I just want to be done - art or money asap so I can mark this as done in my records and stop stressing out over it.

EDIT: I have finally gotten a response, though only after I sent a new note. I've seen her post up repeated new YCH flat priced pieces and auctions and complete personal pieces as well as gift art + a few commissions, but I don't know how much of that is old owed things and how many are new things. I know that she has taken on far too much and is still taking on more work, because of various situations in her life. With that said, I don't think that taking on even more pieces when she's already so far behind is wise - at the very least the older pieces need to be done before the new ones.

I am probably getting a refund she says [as of 2/13/16 when I sent a new note]. She says it may take a while though and will be in payment plans. I'm more than slightly irked by this because I didn't get to pay her in payment plans to order, but it is what it is. I do not consider this resolved and will not until either my art or the money is fully refunded.

EDIT 2: I delayed my response to her for 2 reasons. 1- I needed time to cool off because I was angry. 2- I had some things going on elsewhere. I sent my response to her on 3-3-16 and apologized for the lateness. You can see that here - https://gyazo.com/52a50045a15b08d379c0f54b51c07966 and then noted her again on the 6th when I checked and she'd read it, posted journals and other things, and not responded. You can see that here - https://gyazo.com/e77ff4cfa2fb8b7df3c130ba042e279e . I feel I was fairly neutral, though I am admittedly growing impatient because I just want my money or my art, or at the very least a better estimate than the very vague 'it might be a bit' in the notes. I don't mind if the money isn't right away, but then I saw her taking commissions for spotify premium, which bothered me as I feel a refund should take priority to luxuries of that sort. I have also left a shout on her main page today asking her to please respond to my notes. Both have been read, she's been active places, and I'd really just like this to be resolved. You can see that both have been read here - https://gyazo.com/52a50045a15b08d379c0f54b51c07966

EDIT 3: I left a shout on her page on I want to say the 12th of March. It's been deleted [should have screencapped, my bad] but I did get another response. I proposed swapping the base, as it was a large commission, for a single full body piece since the amount was the same [within the range listed for them, anyway] and after my shout she responded asking me not to leave shouts. I pointed out that's been the only way I get timely responses, but dropped it since I was getting communication now. She agreed to the swap to a single full body piece and is supposed to be updating her queue soon with a public list so everyone can see where they are. While I'm still upset, I'm less angry now that I've gotten some responses and have moved forward on at least swapping for something that should be easier for her to complete and is fair with her rates [admittedly the base was priced quite low for the number of things I'd be getting]. If all goes well and she gets her queue down, I may consider commissioning her again in the future should she be willing as I really do enjoy her art style. Still don't consider this resolved, but will come back to let you know once it is.

EDIT 4: I got my finished piece, and it's perfect. I consider this resolved and would recommend people commission her once she's got her queue down a little bit. She's gotten a lot better about communication and I'm pleased with the outcome.
  • spykr

(no subject)

Who: Inu-Jean
Where: http://www.furaffinity.net/user/inu-jean/
What: Digital art, two characters, finished here http://www.furaffinity.net/view/18266800/ (NSFW)
When: Payment sent November 14, 2014 and image was completed on November 16, 2015
Proof: Payment sent and received: http://imgur.com/vZclyFF
            First Concern raised: http://imgur.com/tK7BMWt
          
Collapse )
Explain: I would first like to say that I hold no ill will towards the artist, nor is this made in any way to defame or try to beat down on him. His work is phenomenal, but both I and my friend (who has had several great experiences with commissioning this artist in the past) feel it’s important for people who may want to commission this particular artist in the future to know that there may be issues during the process. Neither of us believe any bad intentions were made on the artist’s part, but things certainly spiraled nearly out of control and became an almost perfect storm of stuff gone wrong in the commissioning process. However, art was finally delivered, and done so to both my and my fellow commissioner’s satisfaction. I have to admit, I do feel a bit uncomfortable posting this, but after learning that my fellow commisioner shared a similar situation to another commssioner during the same time frame, I think it's important that I do so.

A friend of mine (Alex in the screenshots) and I contacted Inu-Jean for a 2-character commission in November of 2014. Specifics of the commission were worked out over the course of the following few days. We were a ways down from the images he was working on and knew there would be a decent wait involved, which did not bother us. However, the months went by, not a single update was given regarding progress until a (now deleted) update journal was posted to FA in late April announcing that the artist was taking on another batch of commissions. Concerned, my fellow commissioner messaged the artist regarding this, but he did not respond until being messaged once more several weeks later...

Collapse )
  • djoan8

Lyshastra (Furaffinity) / Ann Allen (Facebook)

WHO: Lyshastra (Furaffinity), Ann Allen (Facebook)

WHERE: http://www.furaffinity.net/user/lyshastra
              https://www.facebook.com/people/Ann-Allen/100009386021687

WHAT: Art trade--A bust of her character for a badge (or two) of mine.

WHEN: April 26 -- She asked to do an art trade and we worked out the details          
         May 29 -- I finished and posted my part of the trade
            June 25--September 12 -- A lot of back and forth trying to reach her and find out progress of badge(s)
            October 8 -- I finally see pictures of the actual finished badges
            November 15 (Now) -- Still waiting on scanned versions to be posted
         
PROOF: https://gyazo.com/5ba0e7c507a07c2929f561f3dfccd63d (first asked if I wanted to do a trade)
              https://gyazo.com/8282531b428e9c5d63c3f3614fa19e32  (working out the details--read from bottom to top)
              https://gyazo.com/f3b582256793b7b986dbfe8015bd1f11  (working out details part 2)
              https://gyazo.com/8831e2970df610a0944823025bf277e4  (working out details part 3)
              https://gyazo.com/1c61398cda4e631861b1d5a4b961eae1 (my finished posting)
       
EXPLAIN: On April 26th she asked if I wanted to do an art trade, to which I replied yes and messaged her for the details. I finished my half on May 29th and sent her a note with the finished picture. Some time later she opened the note, but never responded to it. A month later when she did respond, it was not to the note but on the submission.
https://gyazo.com/f1573a3ca5928b8748df3fd50dd16e78
Collapse )


Now I understand that technically she did finally do the badges, and I can probably still try to contact her for the scanned versions, but honestly I don't want to go through all the time and effort again it took just to get to here. If I had written this artists beware earlier as I had planned to, things would be looking a lot worse. At this point I think it's just best to let people know what they could be getting into if they decide to commission her to do a trade.